Dr Ekta Vala ChandaranaMedical Oncologist

Getting a Second Opinion for Cancer: When and How

By Dr Ekta Vala Chandarana, Senior Consultant Medical Oncologist

What is a second opinion?

A second opinion means asking another doctor (usually another cancer specialist) to look at your reports and your treatment plan. They tell you whether they agree, or whether they would suggest something different.

Many patients feel guilty about asking. They worry the first doctor will feel bad. Please don't worry. Getting a second opinion is common in cancer care, and the decision is yours (American Cancer Society). I welcome it when my patients want one. A good doctor wants you to feel sure about your treatment.

Most of the time, the second doctor agrees with the plan. That itself is useful: you can start treatment with more confidence. Sometimes, they add a test or suggest another option to discuss.

When a second opinion can help

You can ask for a second opinion at any time. It is especially worth thinking about when (American Cancer Society):

  • You have a rare or unusual cancer.
  • The diagnosis or the stage is not clear.
  • You are offered a big surgery, or a treatment with serious side effects.
  • You want to know whether other options exist, for example targeted therapy, immunotherapy or a clinical trial.
  • The treatment is not working as hoped, or the cancer has come back.
  • You find it hard to talk with your doctor, or you don't understand the plan.
  • Your insurance company asks for one.
  • You simply want peace of mind.

For breast cancer, I have answered this in more detail in can I take a second opinion before starting breast cancer treatment?

Will it delay my treatment?

For most cancers, taking a short time to be sure of the plan is safe. Some cancers, though, need treatment quickly, for example some fast-growing blood cancers like acute leukemia. If you are worried about waiting, ask your doctor how soon treatment must start (American Cancer Society).

To avoid delay, collect your reports quickly and book the second opinion soon. Often the second doctor can review existing scans and slides without repeating every test.

How to get a second opinion: step by step

  1. Tell your doctor. Say simply, "I'd like a second opinion before we start." Most doctors will help and share your reports.
  2. Choose the doctor. For cancer, choose a specialist in your type of cancer, a medical oncologist for medicine treatments, a surgical oncologist for surgery, or a radiation oncologist for radiation. Your doctor, family doctor or a cancer hospital can suggest names.
  3. Collect your reports (see the list below). Keep the originals with you and share copies.
  4. Get the biopsy slides and blocks if the second doctor wants the pathology checked again. The lab that did your biopsy can give these.
  5. Write down your questions before the visit. Take a family member with you.
  6. Compare and decide. If the two opinions differ, ask each doctor to explain why. You can ask them to talk to each other, or take a third opinion if needed.

A second look at the biopsy

Sometimes the most useful second opinion is not from another oncologist, but from another pathologist (the doctor who studies the biopsy under a microscope). The type of cancer decides the treatment. So if the report is unclear, or the cancer is rare, I may suggest that the slides are reviewed again at another lab.

This is called a pathology review. You don't need another biopsy for it. The first lab gives the slides and tissue blocks, and the second lab checks them. Read more about how cancer is diagnosed.

Papers to bring

A second opinion is only as good as the information the doctor gets. Bring (American Cancer Society):

  • The biopsy or pathology report (the report that confirms the cancer), and IHC or genetic test reports if done
  • Scan reports, and the CDs or online links of the actual images: CT, MRI, PET-CT, mammogram
  • Blood test reports, including tumour markers if done
  • Operation notes and discharge summaries, if you had surgery or a hospital stay
  • The current treatment plan, or chemotherapy records if you have started
  • A list of all medicines you take, with doses
  • Your other health problems, allergies and family history of cancer

Put the papers in date order in one file. It saves a lot of time. If you are travelling from another city, read travelling for cancer treatment.

Coming to me for a second opinion

If you have been diagnosed elsewhere and would like me to review your reports, you are welcome. I am a medical oncologist with 10+ years in oncology practice. I look at your reports, the stage, and the treatment plan, and explain in simple words what I think and why.

If surgery or radiation is part of the question, I may also involve a surgical or radiation oncologist I work with. Please bring all your reports, and contact my clinic to book. You can also read about your visit, step by step.

Questions to ask at a second opinion

  1. Do you agree with the diagnosis and the stage?
  2. Do I need any more tests before starting?
  3. Would you suggest the same treatment? If not, why?
  4. What is the aim of the treatment, cure, control, or comfort?
  5. Are there other options, including clinical trials?
  6. How soon should I start?
  7. What side effects should I expect?
  8. Can the treatment be given near my home?

See also my full list of questions to ask your doctor and, if you are just diagnosed, what to do first.

Questions patients ask me

Is it rude to ask for a second opinion?

No. Second opinions are common in cancer care, and most doctors support them. It is your right to feel sure about your treatment.

Will a second opinion delay my treatment?

Usually not by much, if you collect reports quickly. Some cancers need urgent treatment, so ask your doctor how soon you must start.

Do I need to repeat all the tests?

Usually not. The second doctor can often review your existing scans, reports and biopsy slides. Sometimes one extra test is needed to be sure.

What if the two doctors give different advice?

Ask each doctor to explain their reasons. You can ask them to speak to each other, or take a third opinion. Then choose the plan you understand and trust.

Can I get a second opinion after starting treatment?

Yes. You can ask at any time, for example if the treatment is not working or the side effects are hard. Don't stop your treatment while you wait, talk to your doctor first.

Sources

The facts and numbers on this page come from these sources. Every person is different, so please talk to your own doctor about what applies to you.

CallWhatsApp